Variation orders in construction: how Saudi contractors protect margin with a locked VO column

Variation orders in construction: how Saudi contractors protect margin with a locked VO column

Published By

Umar Shariff
Construction/Contracting
Nov 21, 2026

In short: A variation order (VO) protects your margin only when it lives in its own locked column on the approved BOQ and the project budget, next to an original line that nobody edits. Quantity changes are owned jointly by project management and the technical office; changes to budget value sit with top management only. Contingency lines start at zero and only authorised people raise them, and every approved VO flows to the next progress claim. Below: why variations leak margin, the locked VO column, who may change what, the VO steps from instruction to invoice, a worked SAR example of the effect on contract value, retention and VAT, and a free variation order log for Excel.

The lobby marble was never in the drawings. The client's representative asked for it on a site walk in March, the consultant wrote a site instruction, and the subcontractor started in April. By June the work was finished and photographed. In September the commercial manager found that nobody had priced it, the client had not signed anything, and the original BOQ line for marble had simply been "updated" to the new quantity. The project looked on budget. It was not; it was carrying SAR 168,000 of work nobody had billed.

Most contractors have a version of this story. The variation was real, the work was good, and the money still went missing, because the change was written over the original line instead of beside it.

Why do variation orders leak margin?

A variation is any change to the scope, quantity, specification or timing of the work agreed in the contract: an addition, an omission or a substitution. The change itself is normal. The leak happens in how it is recorded.

Six ways variation orders leak margin: work starts on a verbal instruction, the original BOQ line is overwritten, nobody prices the change, budget and BOQ disagree, approved VOs are never billed, and retention and VAT are worked out by hand
Six ways a variation order loses money
  • Work starts on a word. A verbal or WhatsApp instruction is treated as approval, and nobody can later show who asked.
  • The original line is overwritten. The BOQ quantity is edited, so the contract and the change can no longer be told apart.
  • Nobody prices it in time. The work is finished before a price reaches the client, which leaves you negotiating after the fact.
  • The budget and the BOQ disagree. The client side is updated but the cost budget is not, or the other way round.
  • Approved but never billed. The VO is signed, then forgotten in the monthly claim.
  • Retention and VAT by hand. Each VO changes what is held and what is taxed, and a side spreadsheet gets it wrong.

What is the locked VO column?

The Saudi general contractor in our example keeps a VO column on the approved BOQ and on the project budget. Every line has three numbers that sit side by side and never replace each other:

BOQ line 06-02, marble flooringQuantity (m²)Rate (SAR)Amount (SAR)
Original (approved, locked)4,000140560,000
Variation column (VO-01)+1,200140+168,000
Revised (original + VO)5,200140728,000
The locked VO column on one BOQ line: original 4,000 square metres, locked; variation plus 1,200 square metres from VO-01; revised 5,200 square metres; the original line is never edited
Original, variation and revised quantities side by side

Four rules keep the column honest:

  1. The original line is never edited. After approval the BOQ and budget are locked. If a genuine error must be corrected, a separate role unlocks the line, and the change is logged.
  2. Every VO has a number and a reason. VO-01 on line 06-02 points to the site instruction and the client's approval.
  3. The VO column exists on both sides. The BOQ (what the client pays) and the budget (what the job costs) move together, so the margin on the variation is visible.
  4. The revised figure is calculated, never typed. Revised = original + approved VOs.

If you are new to how a BOQ is built, our guide to BOQ in civil engineering covers the basics first.

Who may change a variation order, and what?

The column only works if few people can touch it. The contractor split the rights this way:

Who changes what on a variation order: nobody edits the original line, project management and the technical office jointly own VO quantities, top management alone owns budget value changes, and only authorised people raise contingency lines that start at zero
Four rights, four owners
  • Original BOQ and budget lines: nobody, once approved.
  • Quantity in the VO column: project management and the technical office together. The project manager knows what the site was told to build; the technical office checks the take-off against the drawings and the instruction.
  • Budget value and rates: top management only. A change in the money the company commits to a project is a decision for management.
  • Contingency lines: these start at zero, and only authorised people raise them, through an additions column.

Contingency covers internal costs the budget missed, and it is kept apart from client variations. In one case the budget for a project manager was about SAR 19,000 a month all-in, covering salary, insurance, iqama, work permit, tickets and end-of-service. Then an unbudgeted SAR 6,000 sponsorship transfer arrived. Instead of quietly stretching another line, an authorised person raised a zero-value contingency line by SAR 6,000, with a reason. The cost became visible, and nobody billed the client for it. For a broader view of sizing contingency, see our contingency budget guide.

What are the steps from instruction to invoice?

Your contract, whether FIDIC-based or a government contract, sets who may instruct a variation and how it is valued. Inside the contractor, the same five steps apply to every VO:

The variation order process in five steps: written instruction, pricing by the technical office and commercial team, client approval, entry in the VO column of the BOQ and budget, and billing in the next progress claim
From instruction to invoice in five steps
  1. Instruction. Get it in writing: a site instruction, the consultant's letter, or the client's request. Give it a VO number the same day, even before it has a price.
  2. Pricing. The technical office measures the quantity; the commercial team prices it from contract rates, or builds a new rate where none fits. Price the cost side too, so you know the margin.
  3. Approval. Submit to the client or consultant. Track the days it waits; a variation that sits unapproved while the work proceeds carries the risk on your side.
  4. Into the column. On approval, the quantity goes into the VO column of the BOQ and the budget. The revised contract value moves with it.
  5. Billing. The approved VO appears as its own line in the next monthly progress claim, measured like any other work.

Decide in advance what happens to work done before approval. Many contractors bill it only once the VO is approved, but they record the quantity done each month so nothing is lost while they wait.

How does a variation order change contract value, retention and VAT?

A worked example on a building contract of SAR 43 million excluding VAT, with 10% retention and VAT at 15%. The rates and figures are illustrative.

VODescriptionTypeValue (SAR)Status
VO-01Marble to lobbies and corridors, 1,200 m² × 140Addition+168,000Approved
VO-02False ceiling omitted in plant rooms, 800 m² × 65Omission−52,000Approved
VO-03Extra blockwork, 600 m² × 85Addition+51,000Awaiting approval
  • Revised contract value: 43,000,000 + 168,000 − 52,000 = SAR 43,116,000. VO-03 is not added until it is approved, but it is reported as exposure: work you may be doing without a price.
  • Billing VO-01 in full: gross 168,000, VAT at 15% 25,200, retention at 10% held back 16,800, so SAR 176,400 is due on that line.
  • Margin on VO-01: if the marble costs SAR 120 per m² to supply and install (about 70 supply and 50 install), the budget VO column adds SAR 144,000 of cost, and the variation earns SAR 24,000.
Worked example on a SAR 43 million contract: VO-01 adds 168,000, VO-02 omits 52,000, the revised contract value is 43,116,000, and billing VO-01 adds 25,200 of VAT and holds 16,800 of retention
What three variations do to contract value, VAT and retention

Two things in this example are easy to miss. The omission reduces the contract, and with it the retention the client holds and the margin on the job. And the retention on VO-01 is money you have earned but will receive only when the client releases it, often after 12 months. Our guide to retention in construction explains the release.

How do you get paid for approved but unbilled variations?

Keep one number on the front page of every project report: approved VOs not yet billed. It is earned money sitting in nobody's claim. Check it in three places every month:

  • The VO log: approved value minus billed to date, for each VO.
  • The progress claim: does every approved VO with work done appear as a line?
  • The age of pending VOs: how many days each has waited for approval since the instruction.

Read the list in the monthly commercial meeting. A pending VO older than 30 days is a letter to the consultant. An approved VO with nothing billed after the work is done is a question for whoever prepared the claim.

Download the free variation order log

The kit puts the method above into one workbook and a short guide:

  • Excel log: a Start here sheet; Settings for the contract value, retention and VAT; the VO register with instruction, pricing, status, approved value, billed and unbilled amounts and days waiting; an approval chain per VO (project manager, technical office, commercial, top management for budget, client); the BOQ effect with original, VO and revised columns; the contract value, retention and billing summary.
  • PDF guide: the locked-column rules, who changes what, the five steps, the worked SAR example, the monthly review and a blank VO form to print.

Where does HAL Contracting fit?

In HAL Contracting, each project records its contract value, advance, performance bond and retention percentages, re-measurement and variation orders. The BOQ keeps the fixed contract quantity while re-measured and variation quantities move beside it, and the original, re-measured, variation and revised budgets are kept side by side, with each change approved through a workflow. Progress claims deduct retention, recover the advance with its VAT and take off penalties, each to its own ledger, and the claims register shows retention held and the balance for every claim. Approval workflows with as many levels as you need can sit on any transaction. See HAL pricing for the plans.

Related reading: monthly progress claims and retention, BOQ budget control for purchase requests and job costing: actual vs estimated cost.

Frequently asked questions

What is a variation order in construction?

A variation order is a recorded change to the work in the contract: an addition, an omission or a substitution of scope, quantity or specification. It carries a number, the instruction it came from, its price and the client's approval, and it changes the contract value once approved.

What is the difference between a change order and a variation order?

They describe the same thing. "Variation order" is the usual term on FIDIC-based contracts and in Saudi Arabia and the Gulf; "change order" is more common in North America. What matters is that it is written, priced, approved and recorded beside the original line.

Who approves variation orders on a Saudi project?

The client or the consultant approves them as the contract sets out. Inside the contractor, project management and the technical office own the quantity, and top management alone approves changes to budget value.

Should the original BOQ line be updated when a variation is approved?

No. The original line stays locked. The variation goes into a separate VO column, and the revised quantity and amount are calculated as original plus approved VOs, so the contract and the change can always be told apart.

How does a variation order affect retention and VAT?

An approved addition raises the contract value, so retention is held on it when it is billed and VAT at 15% is charged on it. An omission reduces both. In the worked example, billing a SAR 168,000 VO adds SAR 25,200 of VAT and SAR 16,800 of retention held.

What is a variation order log?

A variation order log is the register of every VO on a project: number, instruction, description, quantity, rate, value, status, approval dates, billed and unbilled amounts and days waiting. It is the one place to see the revised contract value and what is still to be billed.

Umar Shariff