Job costing for contractors: track actual vs estimated cost every month, with a Saudi example

Job costing for contractors: track actual vs estimated cost every month, with a Saudi example

Published By

Umar Shariff
Construction/Contracting
Nov 21, 2026

In short: Job costing means comparing what each project actually costs with what you estimated, line by line, every month. Give every BOQ line a cost code, record what you have committed (purchase orders and subcontracts) beside what you have actually incurred (receipts, timesheets and certificates), and ask the project manager for the cost to complete. Budget minus forecast at completion shows where the margin is going while there is still time to act. The free job cost sheet (Excel and PDF) does the arithmetic.

Most contractors find out a project lost money after the final account. The tender was priced carefully, the client paid, the site was busy. But the estimate lived in one Excel file, purchases in another, site labour in one payroll for every project, and nobody put the three together until the job was over.

This guide is for contractors, steel and aluminium fabricators and other project-based firms in Saudi Arabia: owners, project managers, cost controllers and finance heads. It shows how to set up cost codes, separate committed from actual cost, cost labour properly (including the iqama, insurance and end-of-service that never appear on the payslip), handle subcontract certificates and retention, and read margin per job each month. A worked example follows one building through month 6.

What is job costing, and why monthly?

Job costing assigns every riyal of cost to the job that caused it and compares it with the job's estimate. For a contractor, the estimate is the priced BOQ broken into materials, labour, subcontract, plant and other costs. The comparison is only useful if it happens while the job is running.

Monthly is the right rhythm because everything else on a Saudi project is monthly: progress claims, subcontractor certificates, payroll and the site stock count. A quarterly review finds an overrun after three claims have gone out at the old margin. A monthly one finds it while you can still re-price a variation, change a supplier or move a crew.

Cost codes: the backbone of job costing

A cost code is the label every cost carries. Without it, a delivery of blocks is just "materials" and cannot be compared with anything.

Construction cost codes for job costing: each BOQ line such as 01-01 concrete columns splits into materials, labour, subcontract, plant and tools, and other costs such as tests and curing
One cost code per BOQ line, split into five cost types
  • Build the code from the BOQ. A short hierarchy works: 01 concrete, 01-01 columns, 01-03 footings; 04 blockwork, 04-01 external walls. Keep the same codes on every project so you can compare jobs; the specification changes (35 or 50 MPa), the code does not.
  • Split each line into cost types. Materials, labour, subcontract, plant and tools, and other (tests, curing, small consumables). This is how the estimator priced it, so it is how you track it.
  • Lock the budget when the contract is signed. Approved variation orders become separate lines or a VO column, so the original estimate stays visible. Only named people (top management for money, the technical office and project management for quantities) can change it.
  • One rule on site. A request can be for less than the BOQ quantity, never more, and never for an item that is not in the BOQ. Anything else goes through a variation or a contingency line that only authorised people can raise.

For the BOQ itself, see our guide to BOQ management in civil engineering.

Committed vs actual cost: the column most reports leave out

Actual cost is what has been incurred: material received, hours worked, work certified. Committed cost is what you have already agreed to pay: purchase orders and subcontracts issued, whether or not the invoice has arrived. Track both against the budget.

Committed versus actual cost on a concrete works line: budget SAR 2.40 million, committed SAR 2.31 million in purchase orders, actual SAR 1.52 million received, forecast at completion SAR 2.38 million
Budget, committed, actual and forecast on one cost line

Why committed matters: on the concrete line in our example, SAR 1.52 million has been received, which looks comfortable against a SAR 2.40 million budget. But SAR 2.31 million is already on purchase orders. Only SAR 90,000 of the budget is uncommitted, with a third of the work left. Without the committed column, the first sign of trouble is an invoice that has already been ordered.

Four rules keep the two columns honest:

  1. Materials count as actual when they are received and accepted, not when the invoice is posted. If your site receives in two steps (the storekeeper checks quantity, then the engineer checks the specification), cost moves at the second step.
  2. Received but not invoiced is still a cost. Accrue it at month-end from the receipt, or the month looks cheaper than it was.
  3. Subcontract cost is the gross certified value. Retention you hold back and advances you recover change what you pay this month, not what the work cost.
  4. Leave out recoverable VAT. A VAT-registered contractor recovers 15% input VAT through its return, so job cost is the amount before VAT.

Labour from timesheets, at all-in cost

Labour is usually the biggest gap between estimate and actual, for two reasons: people move between sites, and their real cost is higher than their salary.

Charge labour by days on each project. A site timesheet per project, approved monthly, says who worked where. A mason with an all-in cost of SAR 3,900 a month and 26 paid days costs SAR 150 a day; 20 days on Tower B puts SAR 3,000 on Tower B. If all salaries post to one payroll ledger, the project report leaves out its biggest cost.

Use all-in cost, not salary. The rate per person should include everything the company pays to keep them on site: medical insurance, iqama and work permit fees, annual tickets, end-of-service accrual and the employer's GOSI contributions. End-of-service alone is half a month's wage per year for the first five years under the Saudi Labour Law, about SAR 625 a month on a SAR 15,000 wage.

All-in staff cost for job costing: a project manager on a SAR 15,000 salary costs about SAR 19,000 a month all-in, and an unbudgeted SAR 6,000 sponsorship transfer made one month SAR 25,000
A project manager's salary, all-in cost and the month with an unbudgeted transfer

A real example from a Saudi general contractor's budget: a project manager on about SAR 15,000 a month was budgeted at SAR 19,000 a month all-in, once insurance, iqama, work permit, tickets and end-of-service were added. Then a SAR 6,000 sponsorship transfer, which nobody had budgeted, landed on the project. The fix the company chose was simple: a zero-value contingency line on each budget that only authorised people can raise, so a surprise like this is approved and visible rather than buried in "staff costs".

For more on site timesheets, see project timesheets: tracking hours and cost.

Subcontracts and certificates

Subcontract cost arrives through monthly certificates, so treat each certificate like a mini progress claim:

  • Certify against the BOQ quantity. The certificate shows quantity done this period and to date, at the subcontract rate. It cannot pass the subcontract quantity without a variation.
  • Split supply from install. If a subcontractor supplies and installs marble, record two lines: supply and install (on one Saudi project, rounded, about SAR 70 per m² and SAR 50 per m²). It shows what you supply yourself, and it helps when a classification review asks.
  • Several subcontractors on one line are normal. One porcelain line might be split between a manufacturer and a distributor; give each its own commitment under the same cost code.
  • Retention and advance recovery are balances, not savings. Track retention payable per subcontractor with its release date, so finance sees the commitment that cost control already knows about.

Worked example: one building at month 6

A Saudi contractor is building a four-storey residential block. Contract value SAR 7,450,000 before VAT; budget (estimated cost) SAR 6,546,000; planned margin SAR 904,000, or 12.1%. Fourteen-month programme; this is the month 6 cost review. The figures are illustrative, not benchmarks.

Cost codeLineBudgetCommittedActual to dateForecast at completionVariance
01Concrete works (materials)2,400,0002,310,0001,520,0002,380,000+20,000
04Blockwork and plaster640,000420,000210,000690,000−50,000
09Marble, supply and install (subcontract)360,000366,0000366,000−6,000
12MEP (subcontract)1,450,0001,450,000435,0001,450,0000
L1Site labour (timesheets)1,100,000560,0001,240,000−140,000
S1Project manager (all-in)266,000120,000272,000−6,000
G1Site overheads, tests and curing330,000150,000330,0000
Total6,546,0002,995,0006,728,000−182,000

How to read it:

  • Forecast at completion = actual to date + the project manager's cost to complete. It can never be lower than what is already committed.
  • Variance = budget − forecast. Negative means overrun.
  • Forecast margin = 7,450,000 − 6,728,000 = SAR 722,000, or 9.7%, down from 12.1%. The job is still profitable, but SAR 182,000 of margin has gone in six months.
  • Where it went: site labour (SAR 140,000; actual SAR 560,000 against SAR 495,000 earned at 45% progress), blockwork (SAR 50,000 after a block price rise), the PM's sponsorship transfer (SAR 6,000) and the marble supply rate (SAR 72 a m² instead of 70, so SAR 6,000).
  • Margin to date: certified revenue SAR 3,280,000 less actual cost SAR 2,995,000 = SAR 285,000 (8.7%). Lower than the forecast because labour is running ahead of progress.
Variance by cost line at month 6: site labour SAR 140,000 over, blockwork SAR 50,000 over, marble and the project manager SAR 6,000 each over, concrete SAR 20,000 under, forecast margin down from 12.1% to 9.7%
Where SAR 182,000 of margin went by month 6

The decision this table supports is concrete: look at the labour on the frame and blockwork now, with eight months left, rather than at the final account.

Warning signs to check every month

Six job costing warning signs: labour ahead of progress, commitments above budget, instructed variations not priced, material idle on site, certificates ahead of work, costs with no project
Six warning signs on a job cost report
  • Labour cost ahead of progress. Actual labour above the budget × % complete by more than a few percent.
  • Commitments above budget on a line. A purchase order or subcontract that takes a line past its budget before the work is done.
  • Variations instructed but not priced. Work the client asked for, being done, with no approved VO value. Cost arrives before revenue.
  • Material idle on site for two or three weeks. Bought too early or for the wrong zone; it ties up cash and goes missing.
  • Certificates ahead of work. A subcontractor certified for more than you can see on site.
  • Costs with no project. Salaries, fuel or petty cash posted to head office because nobody chose a project. They make every job look better than it is.

Also watch the gap between site progress and what the client has certified. Some difference is normal; a gap that keeps growing is cash you have spent and not yet billed.

The monthly job cost routine

When (working days after month-end)WhoWhat
Day 2Site engineers, foremenTimesheets approved per project; receipts on site completed
Day 3Procurement, cost controlOpen POs and subcontracts updated; certificates checked against site quantities
Day 5FinanceReceipts not yet invoiced accrued; payroll posted by project at all-in cost
Day 6Project managerCost to complete for every line, in writing, with a reason for each change
Day 7GM, PM, cost control, financeJob cost review: variance, forecast margin, warning signs, one action per overrun

Keep the meeting short and keep one rule: every negative variance leaves the room with a named owner and a date.

Related reading: monthly progress claims and retention, variation orders on the BOQ and BOQ budget control for purchase requests.

Frequently asked questions

What is job costing in construction?

Job costing is tracking the cost of each project against its estimate, by cost code, every month. Each cost (materials received, labour from timesheets, subcontract certificates and site overheads) is tagged to the job and BOQ line that caused it, and compared with the budget to forecast the final cost and margin.

What is the difference between committed and actual cost?

Committed cost is what you have agreed to pay through purchase orders and subcontracts, even before the invoice arrives. Actual cost is what has been incurred: material received, hours worked, work certified. Comparing both with the budget shows an overrun when the order is placed, not when the invoice is paid.

How do you calculate forecast cost at completion?

Add the actual cost to date and the project manager's estimate of the cost to complete each line. The forecast should never be lower than what is already committed. Budget minus forecast is the variance, and contract value minus total forecast is the forecast margin.

Should labour be costed at salary or all-in cost?

At all-in cost. The company also pays medical insurance, iqama and work permit fees, tickets, end-of-service accrual and the employer's GOSI contributions. A project manager on about SAR 15,000 a month can cost about SAR 19,000 all-in. Costing at salary makes every job look more profitable than it is.

Does retention reduce the subcontract cost of a job?

No. Record the subcontract cost at the gross certified value. Retention you hold back is a balance you owe the subcontractor later, and advance recovery offsets money you already paid. Both change cash this month, not the cost of the work.

Is VAT part of job cost?

For a VAT-registered contractor, no. Input VAT at 15% is recovered through the VAT return, so job cost is recorded before VAT. Only VAT you cannot recover belongs in job cost.

Download the free job cost sheet

The kit has two parts:

  • Excel job cost sheet: settings for the project and contract, cost codes, a job cost sheet per line (budget, approved changes, committed, actual by type, % complete, cost to complete, forecast, variance and warning flags), an all-in labour cost builder with end-of-service accrual, a labour allocation from timesheets, and a one-page job summary with forecast margin. The worked example above is included, clearly marked.
  • PDF guide: cost codes, the committed and actual rules, all-in labour, subcontract certificates, the warning signs, the monthly routine and a printable blank job cost sheet.

Job costing in HAL Contracting

HAL Contracting keeps each project's budget by activity and checks purchase requests and orders against it, counting requests, orders and stock issued as committed. HR moves people between projects with dates, and payroll posts each person's cost to the projects they worked on, by days. The project reconciliation report shows turnover, material, labour, subcontract and margin per project, with budget versus actual by project and cost centre. To see what this costs for your company, read our ERP cost guide for contractors, and for the wider cost control process, cost control in project management.

Umar Shariff